Student sues university over poor quality degree
Why do
you think this student is angry?
Why
do you think a degree could be poor quality?
Fiona Pok enrolled in a business degree at
ARU because she thought it could give her a glittering future job.
But after graduating in 2013, her hopes were dashed. She became angry and
described her degree as a "mickey
mouse" degree.
So she decided to sue the university.
Now she has triumphed after being winning a £61,000 payment. The payment was
agreed between the school and Fiona.
Fiona says this was a win for her and other
disgruntled students.
It also means a win because she had to
fight very strongly against the university.
"In
light of this settlement, I think universities should be careful about what
they promise when advertising. I think they make promises they know that are
not possible.
But a university spokesman said the payment
does not mean Fiona is correct.
The university said they were told be that
it would be easier to pay Fiona than keep fighting.
It all started in 2011 when Fiona moved to
the UK from Hong Kong to study at ARU's Lord Ashcroft International Business
School in Cambridge after being impressed
by the school’s advertising.
She graduated with a first-class degree in
international business strategy in 2013. But she says the university’s claims to
be a "renowned centre of excellence" that offered a "high
quality of teaching" were not true.
She said soon after starting she found out
that things were not true. She hopes that her actions will set a precedent so that students can get
value for their money. And if they don’t then the university can be punished.
Fiona says lecturers arrived late to classes
and said students were often told to "self study" with little help.
She says she was "locked" in a
room by staff members when she tried to protest against the university at her
graduation ceremony.
Fiona says she was forced off the stage
during the graduation ceremony.
Lawyers say this could set a precedent for
other students to also do the same.
Try
to guess the meaning of the words in bold and match them with their closest
meaning from the choices in the right. Some of the answers are very close and
have similar meaning. The meaning of these words is how they are used in the
reading. Some of these words have different meanings in the dictionary
depending on how they are used.
The
answers are below the table.
glittering
|
A
|
1
|
To feel failure, to lose the chance or
opportunity
|
hopes were dashed
|
B
|
2
|
Not real, cheap quality, very poorly made
|
mickey mouse
|
C
|
3
|
The first time for something to happen that
will start a pattern/habit for the same thing to happen in the future
|
triumphed
|
D
|
4
|
To judge something after knowing all the
facts, able to know better after having full or new information
|
disgruntled
|
E
|
5
|
Shiny, exciting, bright
|
In light of this
|
F
|
6
|
Wow! To think of something as very good
|
impressed
|
G
|
7
|
Unhappy, disappointed, unsatisfied with the
result
|
precedent
|
H
|
8
|
To win
|
A=5, B=1, C=2, D=8, E=7, F=4, G=6, H=3
Some example sentences using the new words or phrases from the
meaning of how they are used in the reading to help you understand better.
Las Vegas is a glittering place to be.
My hopes were dashed when I learned that I had failed the test.
Don’t buy cheap mickey mouse products from that man, he
is a cheat.
Liverpool have triumphed in the football/soccer
Champion’s League.
Investors are disgruntled after they found out that
the company had told lies about their profits.
In light of learning the truth many
people want their money back from the school.
Sarah, I was impressed with your excellent writing.
This was the first café to
offer half price coffee for take out. It has set a precedent that many other café’s are copying.
Some questions using the new words/phrases. Try to use the
words/phrases in your answer.
How would you react if you thought you had a glittering future but your hopes
were dashed?
Do you know of/or have you
heard of other mickey mouse
schools/education? Please describe.
How do you feel about Fiona’s triumph? Do you think it is bad or good
for other schools?
Do you think this will set a precedent for other students?
In light of this story, can you think of
some negative results for education? For example schools might increase fees to
pay for extra insurance.
What disgruntles you about education in your country? Why?
What impressed you about Fiona?/What did not impress you about her?